Senior regulators in a formal review panel with microphones
COMESA Energy Institute · Centre 02

Measured by peers. Built to perform.

The Regulatory Peer Review Centre benchmarks every COMESA energy regulator against shared regional principles in two ways: a fast annual virtual review, and in-depth in-country missions where regulators visit regulators, examine the evidence and help design the fix.

21Member States in the review cycle
2review modes: virtual and in-country
5review clusters anchored to regional principles
48hfrom virtual session to executive report
Why peer review

Self-assessment shows what a regulator believes. Peer review shows what it can prove.

Regulators in our region often rate their understanding of a subject well above their ability to apply it. Peer review closes that gap with an external, comparable and respectful check carried out by people who have done the job.

Every review pairs a mature regulator with one or two nascent peers, under an independent moderator. Each session should produce at least one concrete, regional account of how a real problem was solved.

Two professionals in a structured interview at a conference table
Peer to peerReviewers are serving regulators, not consultants
Who benefits

Stronger regulators, stronger markets

Regulators

An honest, comparable scorecard, practical lessons from peers, and a reform plan backed by targeted training.

Governments

Evidence on whether policy and legislation give the regulator the powers and independence it needs.

Investors & power pools

Year-on-year regional trend data and convergence of rules, both preconditions for cross-border trade and Mission 300 capital.

What we review

Five clusters. Nine regional principles.

Every review is anchored to the Regional Electricity Regulatory Principles and their key performance indicators. Each cluster asks one master question.

1

Institutional capacity & market access

How does the framework sustain independence and enforce licensing discipline as supply changes?

2

Transparency, tariffs & consumer protection

What balances fair consumer pricing with the financial viability of the sector?

3

Green transition & renewable integration

How are grid codes and contracts adapted to speed up clean energy integration?

4

Third-party access & competition

How is a level playing field kept while the sector stays attractive to private capital?

5

Grid rules, governance & regional alignment

How robust and independently governed is the rule base that lets a Member State trade power across its borders?

Mode 1 · VPR-5 Virtual Peer Review

Five hours. Five clusters. One clear scorecard.

VPR-5 runs every year for each Member State on a rotating basis. It is low-cost, fast and comparable from year to year. Sessions are produced from the Institute’s virtual review studio with interpretation booths.

Transmission towers and power lines at dusk
  1. 1Day –14

    Pre-meeting briefing

    The reviewed regulator submits its briefing pack and evidence two weeks ahead.

  2. 2Block 1

    Regulator panel: clusters 1–3

    Capacity and market access, tariffs and consumers, renewable integration.

  3. 3Pause

    Screen-breather

    A protected break that keeps the panel sharp.

  4. 4Block 2

    Regulator panel: clusters 4–5

    Third-party access and competition, grid rules and regional alignment.

  5. 5Sprint

    Ministry sprint

    Policy and legislative alignment with the responsible ministry.

  6. 6Sprint

    Utility & private-sector sprint

    Grounds the review in commercial reality.

  7. 7Closed

    Moderator scoring window

    Independent, protected scoring against the cluster indicators.

  8. 8+48 hours

    Executive report

    A cluster-by-cluster score and priority actions, delivered within two days.

Mode 2 · In-Country Peer Review Missions

When a regulator needs more than a scorecard

Some questions cannot be answered on a screen. In-country missions put senior peer regulators inside the reviewed institution to see how decisions are actually made, recorded and enforced.

Young engineer in a hard hat at an electrical substation

A mission is triggered when

  • a regulator or its government requests an in-depth review;
  • VPR-5 scores in a cluster stay persistently low across cycles;
  • a Member State undertakes major reform, such as a new energy act, unbundling or market opening;
  • a new regulator joins RAERESA and wants a baseline;
  • the region needs a thematic review, for example of tariff methods or renewable auctions.

The mission team

  • Three to four senior peer regulators, mixing mature and nascent institutions and language groups
  • An independent lead moderator from the regional moderator pool
  • A thematic expert where the scope requires one
  • A CEI rapporteur who manages evidence and drafts the report

Request & scoping

Terms of reference agreed with the regulator: clusters in scope, stakeholders, sites and dates.

Self-assessment & evidence

The regulator completes the cluster self-assessment and submits decisions, models and records ahead of the visit.

On-site mission

Several days of interviews with the board, management, ministry, utilities, IPPs and consumer bodies, plus verification of registers, tariff models, metering and complaint records.

Exit briefing & validation

Headline findings shared before departure. A draft report follows and is validated with the regulator.

Peer dialogue

Findings and lessons are presented to fellow regulators at RAERESA, so the whole region learns.

Action plan & follow-up

A time-bound reform plan, targeted training from the Energy Training Centre, and a progress review within 12 to 18 months.

At a glance

Virtual and in-country, side by side

Mode 1VPR-5 Virtual Peer ReviewMode 2In-Country Peer Review Mission
PurposeAnnual, comparable regulatory health checkIn-depth institutional diagnosis and reform design
FrequencyEvery year, rotating across all Member StatesOn request, by finding, or at major reform
FormatOne structured five-hour online sessionSeveral days on site, plus preparation and follow-up
TeamPeer panel and independent moderator3–4 senior peers, lead moderator, rapporteur, thematic expert
EvidenceBriefing submission and panel dialogueInterviews, document review and site verification
OutputCluster scorecard and executive report within 48 hoursFull review report, validated action plan, follow-up review
Best forTracking progress and regional trendsPersistent gaps, major reform, new members
From finding to fix

Every gap we find comes with a way to close it

Review findings flow straight into the Energy Training Centre’s annual planning. A regulator that scores low is offered the course built for that gap.

Low on access

CEI-201 · Grid Codes & Third-Party Access

Offered when the third-party access cluster scores low

Low on grid rules

CEI-204 · System Operations

Offered when grid rules and regional alignment score low

Low on tariffs

CEI-101 · Cost-of-Service Tariffs

Offered when tariffs and consumer protection score low

The share of training enrolments traced to a review finding is a tracked indicator of the Institute.

African women professionals in a collaborative validation workshop Validation and peer dialogue
Our principles

How we review

Peer, not inspector

Reviews are collegial. The aim is improvement, not ranking for its own sake.

Independent scoring

Moderators score against published indicators, and samples are checked for consistency across moderators.

Multilingual

Reviews in English, French and Arabic, with bilingual experts and interpretation.

Owned by the reviewed

The reviewed regulator owns its report. Regional trends are published in aggregate.

Questions

Peer review, plainly answered

Who carries out the reviews?
Serving senior staff of COMESA energy regulators, nominated by their institutions for each cycle, working with independent moderators. For VPR-5, moderators are nominated and trained by the African Development Bank, which also approves the annual schedule and samples score sheets for consistency.
Does a low score carry penalties?
No. Peer review is a diagnostic and learning tool. A low score leads to targeted support: training, peer mentoring and, where useful, an in-country mission.
How do we request an in-country mission?
The head of the regulator, or the responsible ministry, writes to the RAERESA Chief Executive with the proposed scope. The Centre agrees terms of reference, the team and dates with the regulator.
Are review reports published?
The reviewed regulator owns its report and decides on publication. The Institute publishes anonymised regional trends so that every Member State can benchmark itself.
How does this link to training?
Every year the Peer Review Centre and the Energy Training Centre review cluster scores together and offer each Member State the courses that match its gaps.
Request a review

Ready to see your institution through a peer’s eyes?

Regulators and ministries can request an in-country mission, confirm their place in the VPR-5 cycle, or nominate senior staff to the regional pool of peer reviewers.